(855) 603-3325


Trex Transcend® Lineage Composite Fascia Board

Experience Excellent Service in Butler, NJ 

Welcome to our new Butler location, formerly known as Excelsior! This store is a central landmark for homeowners in the region. A trusted source for quality lumber, decking, and other building materials, this location boasts an incredible selection of stock for your next project.

At our Butler store, customers receive the same exemplary care and customer service from our team that defines all of The Deck Store’s full-service locations. Whatever your Butler and Newark NJ lumber needs, we have plenty of building supplies, engineered lumber, and other quality products for you!


BUTLER, NJ 07405

PHONE: (973) 838-1515

HOURS: 7:00 AM–4:00 PM MON-FRI

If you’re in the area, come see us at our Butler, NJ store and meet our team. The location is easily accessible through Hamburg Turnpike and serves the greater New Jersey area, including Newark NJ, and surrounding counties.

We are proud to provide high-quality building materials for docks and decking in Butler, Kinnelon, Riverdale, Pompton Lakes, Oakland, Morris County, and beyond. 

Our Locations

Our Butler, NJ store is just one of the members of our The Deck Store family. We also have locations in Greenville, Indianapolis, Knoxville, Nashville, and Newport News – and we’re growing! Stop by, and we’ll help you find whatever you need. 

Not close to a retail store? No problem. We ship via freight to just about anywhere. Contact us online or call any of our locations listed below to learn more.

A Long History of NJ Service

Formerly Excelsior Lumber Company, this location did not originate as a lumber company when established in 1880 by Benjamin B. Demarest. Positioned by the Pequannock River, the lumber yard produced all types of premium excelsior engineered lumber—a material used exclusively in mattresses—from poplar, spruce, basswood, butternut, willow, and white pine cone. In 1912, the millwork company was incorporated as the North Jersey Excelsior Company.

Seven years after the mill unfortunately burned in 1915, Leo Lust bought the millwork land, creating the Excelsior Lumber Company on the site. Around the same time, Lust expanded to include a mill and shop to provide building products for the community.

In 1971, Excelsior Lumber Company was sold to Gerry Meany, who oversaw the operation, including a mill, hardware store, and lumberyard, for more than 45 years. Near the close of the 80s, the lumber company changed hands to Bob Kaslander Sr. and his son, Bob Kaslander Jr. The organization was shaped into what we now know as Excelsior Lumber Company, offering premier building supplies to Newark NJ, and the greater Jersey area.

Excelsior Lumber Company became one of the state's leading lumber yards, hardware stores, and outdoor living centers in the NJ Newark area! In 2004, the site expanded to include a successful kitchen and bath design showroom to better provide building products and supplies and inspire homeowners across the state.

In 2023, the location was acquired by The Deck Store and continues to serve the local community by providing top-of-the-line building materials, decking, and competitive pricing.

Our friendly staff can't wait to open the door for you and welcome you to our business, whether you hail from Newark or anywhere else in Jersey!